As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Commissions never affect our picks. Read our affiliate disclaimer.
The best refrigerator ice maker replacement matches your fridge’s part number so it plugs into the same harness and fits the same mounting. Ice makers fail often, and a replacement is usually a 20 to 30 minute job.
We compared OEM and aftermarket ice makers on Amazon on part numbers, cross-references and owner feedback.
Quick Answer: The Best Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement
- Best OverallFrigidaire 241798224 Ice Maker
- Best SamsungSamsung DA97-15217D
- Best OEM FrigidaireFrigidaire 241798231 OEM
- Best Older WhirlpoolWhirlpool W10190965 Ice Maker
- Best Whirlpool SxSWhirlpool WPW10300022 OEM
- Best Budget FrigidaireREEPLAR 241798231
KITCHEN BASICS 101 241798224 is the best refrigerator ice maker replacement for Frigidaire, Electrolux and Kenmore owners: over 9,000 owner ratings and a long cross-reference list. Samsung DA97-15217D is genuine OEM, Frigidaire 241798231 is the OEM kit, ClimaTek fits Whirlpool W10190965, Whirlpool WPW10300022 is OEM for side-by-sides and REEPLAR is the budget Frigidaire pick.
Best Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement Comparison Table
| Product | Best For | Type | Key Feature | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frigidaire 241798224 Ice Maker | Best Overall | Replacement ice maker | 241798224, 9,484 ratings | Check Price |
| Samsung DA97-15217D | Best Samsung | OEM ice maker | DA97-15217D OEM | Check Price |
| Frigidaire 241798231 OEM | Best OEM Frigidaire | OEM ice maker kit | 241798231 kit | Check Price |
| Whirlpool W10190965 Ice Maker | Best Older Whirlpool | Replacement ice maker | W10190965 | Check Price |
| Whirlpool WPW10300022 OEM | Best Whirlpool SxS | OEM ice maker | WPW10300022 OEM | Check Price |
| REEPLAR 241798231 | Best Budget Frigidaire | Replacement ice maker | 241798231 copy | Check Price |
The 6 Parts We Recommend
Check that the water line, valve and fill tube are working before blaming the ice maker.
1. KITCHEN BASICS 101 241798224 Ice Maker for Frigidaire, Electrolux, Kenmore
1. KITCHEN BASICS is proven.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Most-reviewed ice maker here
- Long cross-reference
- Auto shut-off arm
- Half the price of OEM
Cons
- Not universal
- Generic
- Check harness
📄 Detailed Review
- Part number: 241798224 / 241642511
- Replaces: 241798201, 5304456671, 241642501, 241798211 and more
- Output: 8 cubes per cycle
- Shut-off: Automatic arm
- Weight: 2.9 lb
- Ratings: 9,484 owner ratings
This KITCHEN BASICS 101 ice maker has over 9,000 owner ratings and replaces a long list of Frigidaire and Electrolux numbers, including 241798224 and 241642511.
Auto shut-off arm.
2. Samsung DA97-15217D Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly
2. Samsung genuine part.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Genuine Samsung
- Covers several older numbers
- Many ratings
- Exact fit
Cons
- Expensive
- Samsung only
- Install can be fiddly
📄 Detailed Review
- Part number: DA97-15217D
- Replaces: DA97-15217A, -15217B, DA97-15335A, DA97-12317A/B
- Type: Genuine Samsung OEM
- Weight: 2.94 lb
- Brand: Samsung
- Ratings: 1,567 owner ratings
Samsung’s genuine DA97-15217D ice maker replaces DA97-15217A, DA97-15217B and DA97-12317 versions.
Covers older numbers.
3. Frigidaire 241798231 Ice Maker Assembly Kit
3. Frigidaire made it.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Genuine OEM
- Engineered to spec
- Kit includes harness
- Clear tools list
Cons
- Costs about twice the copies
- Same fit list only
- White only
📄 Detailed Review
- Part number: 241798231
- Type: Genuine Frigidaire
- Voltage: 120V
- Size: 11.75 x 4.62 x 4.12 in.
- Tools: 1/4 in. nut driver
- Ratings: 622 owner ratings
Frigidaire’s own 241798231 kit is the genuine version of the ice maker that many aftermarket units copy.
Harness included.
4. ClimaTek Bare Ice Maker for Whirlpool WPW10190965
4. ClimaTek fits old numbers.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Covers older Whirlpool numbers
- Many ratings
- Cheaper than OEM
- Simple swap
Cons
- Bare unit, no fill tube
- Thin listing text
- Check harness
📄 Detailed Review
- Part numbers: WPW10190965, W10190965, D7824706Q, 4317943, 1129313
- Voltage: 115V
- Type: Bare ice maker
- Brand: ClimaTek
- Weight: 2.64 lb
- Ratings: 1,007 owner ratings
ClimaTek’s bare ice maker replaces Whirlpool W10190965 and older numbers such as D7824706Q and 4317943.
Cheaper than OEM.
5. Whirlpool WPW10300022 Genuine OEM Side-by-Side Ice Maker
5. Genuine Whirlpool.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Genuine OEM
- Side-by-side fit
- Whirlpool standards
- Clear part list
Cons
- Expensive
- SxS models only
- Fewer ratings
📄 Detailed Review
- Part number: WPW10300022
- Replaces: W10122556, W10300022, W10377190
- Type: Genuine Whirlpool OEM
- Fits: Side-by-side refrigerators
- Weight: 3.21 lb
- Ratings: 210 owner ratings
Whirlpool’s genuine WPW10300022 ice maker is for side-by-side refrigerators and replaces W10122556 and W10377190.
Side-by-side fit.
6. REEPLAR 241798231 / 241798224 Ice Maker Replacement
6. REEPLAR is cheapest.
👍 Pros & Cons
Pros
- Cheapest Frigidaire ice maker here
- Long cross-reference
- Not-universal warning
- Many ratings
Cons
- Fits only listed models
- Generic
- Harness may differ
📄 Detailed Review
- Part numbers: 241798231, 241798224, 241798211, 241642511
- Fits: Some Frigidaire, Electrolux, Kenmore (not universal)
- Voltage: 115V
- Size: 6 x 5 x 12 in.
- Weight: 3.04 lb
- Ratings: 778 owner ratings
REEPLAR’s ice maker covers the same Frigidaire numbers as the OEM 241798231 at a lower price.
Not universal.
How We Chose the Best Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement
To choose the best refrigerator ice maker replacement, we compared replacement refrigerator parts sold on Amazon in the U.S., including genuine OEM parts and aftermarket copies. We checked part numbers and cross-reference numbers, listed fit, dimensions, voltage and what comes in the box, and read owner reviews for recurring problems such as wrong fit, noisy motors, leaks, cracked plastic and short life. Because the right part depends on your exact model number, every pick below lists the numbers it replaces, and our guide explains how to confirm the fit before you order.
We checked efficiency claims against ENERGY STAR refrigerator guidance and food-safety temperatures against the FDA’s food storage advice (40°F or colder in the fridge, 0°F in the freezer). Our full process is explained on our How We Test page. We do not list prices or star ratings because they change daily.
How to Choose the Best Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement
Rule out water supply
Check the valve, line and filter first.
Part number
Find the number on the ice maker label.
OEM or copy
OEM costs more; copies list the OEM numbers they replace.
Harness
Make sure the plug matches.
Find your model number before you shop
Every refrigerator has a model and serial number label. Look on the inside wall of the fresh food section, on the ceiling, behind the crisper drawers, or on the door frame. Write down the full number including any suffix letters, because small changes in the suffix can mean a different part. Enter that number on the manufacturer’s parts site or a parts retailer to see the exact diagram and part numbers.
OEM vs aftermarket parts
Genuine OEM parts are made or approved by the refrigerator brand and match the original fit exactly, but they usually cost more. Aftermarket parts copy the OEM design and list the OEM numbers they replace. Many work well, especially simple parts like bins, bulbs and shelves. For electrical parts such as relays, valves and fan motors, read the listing’s compatibility notes carefully and keep the packaging until you confirm the fit.
Using cross-reference numbers
Manufacturers often replace a part number with a newer one, so one part can have several valid numbers. Listings show these as replaces or cross-reference numbers. If your old part shows a number that appears in the listing’s list, it is likely the same part. If it does not, check the brand’s parts diagram for your model before ordering.
Safety before any repair
Unplug the refrigerator before touching any electrical part, and shut off the water supply before working on valves or ice makers. Wear gloves when handling glass shelves and sheet metal edges. Never open the sealed refrigerant system yourself; compressor and refrigerant work requires an EPA-certified technician in the U.S.
Tips for a Smooth Refrigerator Repair
- Turn off the water. Before removal.
- Unplug the fridge. Safety.
- Discard the first batches. Flush the line.
- Keep the freezer at 0°F. Ice makers need cold.
Below are common questions readers ask about choosing the best refrigerator ice maker replacement.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best refrigerator ice maker replacement?
The one matching your part number: 241798224 for Frigidaire, DA97-15217D for Samsung, W10190965 or WPW10300022 for Whirlpool.
Why is my ice maker not making ice?
Often a water supply, valve or temperature problem, not the ice maker itself.
Are aftermarket ice makers reliable?
Many have thousands of positive ratings; check the fit.
How long does install take?
Usually 20 to 30 minutes.
Should I replace the water valve too?
Only if it is faulty.
Where is my refrigerator model number?
Usually on a label inside the fresh food section, on the ceiling, behind the crisper drawers or on the door frame.
Final Verdict
KITCHEN BASICS 101 241798224 is the best refrigerator ice maker replacement for Frigidaire-family fridges, with Samsung DA97-15217D and Whirlpool WPW10300022 as OEM picks. Rule out the water supply first, then install the best refrigerator ice maker replacement for your number.
Related Guides
More refrigerator research from Best Refrigerator Deals:
Prices and availability change often. Check the retailer listing for the current price, warranty and exact dimensions before you buy.
